Ah and the plot thickens. Following some instructions in the wiki I set a mirror to seanmedley.dreamhosters.com to see if I could get it to load. I receive this error both there and at seanmmedley.com (changed this to redirect):
error id: "bad_httpd_conf"
On a whim, I plugged both seanmmedley.com and seanmedley.dreamhosters.com into whatsmydns.net. They both showed global propagation. seanmedley.com still shows none. Is this standard behavior for a mirror and/or redirect or is it looking like the issue is specific to my main website domain?
Ah yes, and the whois domain search shows the DH servers for seanmmedley.com but still not for seanmedley.com.