When I view server.botnik.com.
Weird results showing from http://www.whatsmydns.net/#A/server.botnik.com though.
I looked at the DNS settings on your Panel, and you have that second IP (22.214.171.124) listed in the custom settings. That's the one that shows me the restAPI. However the DreamHost ones below are showing the other IP.
I don't know how to correct that, but I'm pretty sure that's why you get those weird and inconsistant results. Open up a support ticket and show them that, I think they can fix that for you