Did you read the "*" text that further describes the $5.95 a month rate?
"* paid 10 years in advance. $10.95/mo monthly, $9.95/mo for 1 year, $8.95/mo for 2 years, $7.95/mo for 3 years, $6.95/mo for 5 years. $49.95 set up fee if you pay monthly."
If you are currently paying $7.95 a month for 2 years in advance, this new plan will increase your monthly fee by one dollar a month if you sign up for it for 2 years (to $8.95).
To get the $5.95 a month, you need to sign up and pay in advance for 10 years.